11 · November

Be consistent, not generous

A small feeder refilled daily teaches birds a reliable route. A huge feeder filled once and left empty for a fortnight does not.

  • Black-oil sunflower
  • Suet
  • Peanuts
November: be consistent, not generous
Photo: Per from Kaministiquia, Canada · CC BY-SA 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

At a glance

Put out
Black-oil sunflower, Suet, Peanuts
Birds to expect
Dark-eyed Junco, Black-capped Chickadee, Northern Cardinal, House Finch, and 3 more
Main job
Pick a feeder you can realistically refill daily.
Watch for
Consistency beats quantity: a small feeder refilled daily teaches birds a reliable route.

What is changing this month

The feeding pattern settles into winter. Reliability now matters more than variety.

Birds to expect in November

Most often reported at feeders this month. What turns up depends on your region and the weather, so treat it as a starting point.

Feeder jobs for November

  • Pick a feeder you can realistically refill daily.
  • Top up before the weather turns, not during a storm.
  • Keep water ice-free as hard frosts begin.

Water in November

Hard frosts make liquid water scarce. Keep one bath ice-free and shallow.

Species in focus: Dark-eyed Junco

Dark-eyed Junco

Juncos are the backbone of many winter feeders. They feed on the ground, so millet below the feeder often matters more than the feeder itself.

Food
Millet & corn, Sunflower
Feeder
Ground or low platform
Season
Autumn to spring (winter visitor in many areas)
Full profile

What to watch for

  • Consistency beats quantity: a small feeder refilled daily teaches birds a reliable route.
  • Do not let a large feeder sit empty for a fortnight, then refill — reliability is the point.
  • Top up before the weather turns rather than during a storm.
  • Keep water ice-free as hard frosts begin.

Three things not to do

  • Don't start a big feeder you cannot keep filled.
  • Don't let a feeder sit empty for weeks and then refill — reliability is the point.
  • Don't take feeders down mid-winter if you can avoid it.

Check this locally

Timing shifts with latitude, elevation and the year. Use these as pointers, then check what is actually happening near you.

  • North: snow cover is likely; feeder use is heavy and constant.
  • Mid-latitudes: the winter pattern is establishing.
  • South: many winter residents are present but weather is milder.

Questions this month raises

Is it better to feed a little every day or a lot once?

A small feeder refilled daily teaches birds a reliable route. A large feeder that sits empty for a fortnight does not.

What if I go away?

Fill everything before you leave. A gap of a week or two is not a crisis, but avoid taking a feeder down mid-winter if you can help it.

Do birds become dependent on feeders?

There is no strong evidence that garden feeding creates a population that would starve without it. Feeding is a supplement.